I've Been Served With a Lawsuit — Now What?

← Back to Blog

You answered the door, or checked your mail, and now you're holding a stack of legal papers with your name on them. A lawsuit has been filed against you. The envelope might say "Summons and Complaint," or it might just look official and alarming. Either way, your stomach dropped.

Take a breath. Being served with a lawsuit does not mean you've lost. It means a process has started — and that process gives you specific rights, specific deadlines, and real opportunities to defend yourself. Here's what you need to understand right now.

What You Were Just Handed

When you're served with a lawsuit in Utah, you typically receive two documents:

The Summons is the official notice that you are being sued. It tells you who is suing you, in what court, and critically — how many days you have to respond.

The Complaint is the actual lawsuit. It lays out what the plaintiff (the person suing you) claims you did, what they're asking for, and the legal basis for their claims. Read it carefully. Every paragraph matters.

Together, these documents start the clock on one of the most important deadlines in civil litigation.

The Deadline Is Everything

In Utah state court, you generally have 21 days from the date you were served to file a written response called an Answer. In federal court, the deadline is typically 21 days as well, though it can be extended in some circumstances.

This deadline is not flexible. Missing it has one consequence that is difficult to undo: a default judgment against you.

Your Response Deadline at a Glance

What Goes Into an Answer

An Answer is not simply saying "I disagree." It is a formal legal document filed with the court that responds to every numbered paragraph in the Complaint. For each allegation, you admit it, deny it, or state that you lack sufficient information to admit or deny it. Anything you don't specifically deny can be deemed admitted.

Your Answer is also your opportunity to raise affirmative defenses — legal arguments that, even if the plaintiff's facts are true, defeat or limit their claims. Common defenses include the statute of limitations (the plaintiff waited too long to sue), failure to mitigate damages, waiver, estoppel, and others depending on the type of case. Defenses not raised in your Answer may be waived forever.

This is one reason why having an attorney draft your Answer matters — not just what you say, but what you preserve the right to argue later.

What Kind of Lawsuit Is It?

The nature of the case affects your strategy significantly. Common types of civil lawsuits people get served with in Utah include:

Debt collection. A creditor or debt buyer suing for money owed. These cases often have statute of limitations defenses, and the plaintiff's documentation is frequently incomplete or incorrect.

Personal injury. Someone claiming you caused them harm — a car accident, a slip on your property, etc. Your insurance company may have an obligation to defend you — call them immediately.

Eviction (unlawful detainer). A landlord suing to remove you from a property. These cases move extremely fast in Utah — sometimes with hearings within 10 days of filing. See our article on eviction mills if this applies to you.

Contract disputes. A business, former employer, or individual claiming you breached an agreement. The contract itself and any communications around it are central evidence.

Small claims. Claims under $11,000 in Utah are often filed in small claims court, where the rules are simpler but the stakes can still be significant.

Things You Should Not Do After Being Served

Do not ignore it. There is no scenario where ignoring a lawsuit improves your situation. Every day you wait is a day closer to a default judgment.

Do not contact the plaintiff directly. Anything you say — by text, email, phone, or in person — can be used as evidence. Direct communications without an attorney often make things worse.

Do not post about it on social media. Social media posts are discoverable evidence. Courts have seen cases lost because of what someone said on Facebook after being served.

Do not destroy documents. Once you've been served, you have a legal obligation to preserve evidence that might be relevant to the case. Destroying records after this point can result in sanctions and adverse inferences at trial.

What Happens Next If You Respond

Once you file an Answer, the case enters what's called the "discovery" phase. Both sides exchange information: documents, written questions (interrogatories), depositions. This phase can last months. After discovery, there may be motions — requests for the court to rule on legal issues before trial. Many cases settle during or after discovery once both sides see the evidence.

Most civil lawsuits in Utah never reach trial. Having an attorney who understands the discovery process, knows how to evaluate settlement, and is prepared to go to trial if necessary puts you in a fundamentally different position than someone going it alone.

Can You Represent Yourself?

Yes — in Utah, you have the right to represent yourself, called proceeding "pro se." For simple small claims matters, this can be workable. For anything involving significant money, property, or complex legal claims, self-representation carries serious risks. Courts expect pro se litigants to follow the same rules as attorneys. Judges cannot give you legal advice, and procedural mistakes can cost you your case regardless of whether you were right on the merits.

At minimum, a consultation with an attorney before you respond can help you understand what you're dealing with and whether the cost of representation is justified.

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Deadlines and procedures vary by case type and court. Contact an attorney to discuss your specific situation.